Manager or Doer - Which One are You?

Managers fall into a trap, quite easily when thefails, just when it is critical to have someone
pressure is on, of doing more of the regularleading from the front. Respect is lost.
workload that their employees could. It makesThirdly, the lack of development provided by a
them feel like they are achieving more personally,manager to each and every one of their people
as well as fighting the fires that crop up everygenerates a boredom with the job. With little
day. But this is not a sustainable solution, here'schallenge, the job becomes repetitive. With little
why...time for their employees, even praise becomes a
Most managers are measured on tangible results.rarity.
It could be sales, or response times or productionFinally, absenteeism and turnover increase. The
output. It is often number related and with this inhard working manager, doing their now 'day-job',
mind, many managers seek to beef up theis placed faces more tactical demands as he or
manpower delivering these numbers, by doingshe puts the 'doing' work in, to just keep up. As
some of this work themselves.they have less and less capable people, inevitably,
There is nothing wrong with a manager choosingsomething falls off the cliff.
to get their 'hands dirty'. To chip in with theirTypically the business starts to underperform and
people. In fact, when it really matters, it can be athe manager gets put under pressure from
valuable motivational activity, building team spirit.above, often failing under the strain of
But as resources get stretched and the managerself-imposed workload - but the wrong workload.
becomes an integral part of the workforce, theChallenging though it may be, a manager has to
business starts to get dependent on their tacticalstep back from much of this 'doing' stuff in the
input.workplace.
And this stops being a management role, but aShort-term, things may get worse, but for the
'doing' role. At it goes on and on, with no time tolonger-term growth of the business, the manager
develop people and strategies to make thehas to manage their people effectively. Easy
business truly grow, develop and evolve. There issteps in this are spending time building
no time for the really important stuff whichrelationships, defining robust standards,
grows teams and individuals to improve andcommunicating effectively and managing
enhance their contribution.performance.
And so the problems start.Time spent here will be much more value-creating
Firstly, the manager becomes unable to spendfor a manager in developing their people and the
valuable time with team members and understandbusiness for which they are responsible, as well as
what they are feeling, or build credible relationshipsproviding a fulfilling role for them.
with them. These are vital to develop anManager or 'doer' - it is a choice and one which
awareness of issues that are arising in thecan take some time and effort to master. With it
workplace and to get to know individuals'comes the maturity of realising where the future
difficulties and aspirations, for future teamlies - and what it looks like.
development.At the end of the day, as an alternative, stepping
Secondly, employees begin to regard theback from management and becoming a great
manager as just another employee, at their level,'doer', with the respect that brings is no failing.
and the discipline afforded to someone in seniority